Show Notes
This week on Huntavore, Nick welcomes back good friend Mitch Shirk of the Pennsylvania Woodsman Podcast to talk about an exciting upcoming adventure: Nick's first-ever black bear hunt. What started as a long-standing invitation from Mitch has finally come together, and the two break down what listeners can expect from a New Jersey bear hunting experience.
The conversation begins with plenty of campfire humor, including stories about hunting trophies, taxidermy negotiations with spouses, and the challenge of finding wall space for mounts. Nick shares the story behind his Michigan ten-point buck mount while Mitch recounts the unforgettable moment his wife came home to find a full elk shoulder mount hanging in the foyer.
From there, the discussion turns to the surprising reality of New Jersey's bear population. Mitch explains why the northern part of the state offers exceptional bear habitat, how management changes have affected bear numbers, and why human-bear conflicts led to the reopening of the state's bear season. Listeners will gain insight into the dense swamps, abundant food sources, and unique terrain that make New Jersey one of the most productive bear hunting destinations in the East.
Nick and Mitch dive into bear behavior, discussing everything from preferred food sources and swamp habitat to the impressive size of New Jersey black bears. Mitch shares stories of bears weighing over 500 pounds and describes the excitement of encountering an animal that can seemingly appear out of nowhere despite its massive size. The pair also discuss the different age classes of bears, sow and cub interactions, and how hunting can play an important role in managing populations and reducing conflicts.
The conversation shifts into hunting strategy as Mitch explains how he uses bait sites, trail cameras, terrain features, wind direction, and natural travel corridors to increase the odds of success. Rather than simply sitting over bait, he focuses on understanding bear movement and positioning hunters where bears naturally travel. His goal is to provide multiple opportunities and backup plans throughout the three-day hunt.
Listeners will also hear a detailed discussion on shot placement for black bears. Mitch explains why bear anatomy differs from deer, where he recommends placing a shot with both firearms and archery equipment, and why he favors heavy bullets for muzzleloader hunting. The two compare bear and deer anatomy while emphasizing quick, ethical harvests and efficient recoveries.
As always, the conversation eventually finds its way back to food. Mitch makes a strong case for black bear as one of the best wild game meats available, explaining how proper handling, rapid cooling, and careful processing make all the difference. The two discuss bear roasts, burgers, backstraps, sous vide cooking, seasoning techniques, and their plans to experiment with bear recipes if the hunt is successful.
The episode wraps up with anticipation for the upcoming hunt. Nick reflects on the excitement, nervousness, curiosity, and respect that come with pursuing a new species. For him, this adventure represents everything that draws hunters outdoors—the opportunity to explore unfamiliar places, learn new skills, and connect more deeply with the food they bring home.
In This Episode
- Preparing for a first black bear hunt
- New Jersey bear hunting opportunities and regulations
- Bear habitat, food sources, and movement patterns
- Public land scouting and hunting strategy
- Trail cameras, baiting, and wind considerations
- Bear shot placement and anatomy
- Muzzleloader hunting for black bears
- Bear recovery and field dressing
- Why proper meat care matters
- Cooking and processing black bear
- Camp life, camaraderie, and hunting traditions
Guest
Mitch Shirk
Host of the Pennsylvania Woodsman Podcast and longtime bear hunter who shares his experience hunting black bears across Pennsylvania and New Jersey while helping new hunters experience their first bear hunts.
Connect with Mitch
- Pennsylvania Woodsman Podcast
- Sportsmen's Empire Network
- Available wherever you listen to podcasts
Huntavore Takeaway
Sometimes the best hunting adventures start with saying "yes" to something completely new. Whether it's a new species, a new state, or a new group of hunting partners, growth happens when we step into unfamiliar territory. The anticipation, preparation, and shared experiences often become just as meaningful as the harvest itself.
